Showing posts with label 1L. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1L. Show all posts

Saturday, 28 July 2012

Little Darcy Hookhands

Little Darcy Hookhands
Based on a true story

 

Darcy, like the rest of us, was excited about her first year of law school.  She sat in the second row, opposite of me, and watched the teacher intently.  Her arms were folded, sometimes in her lap, or sometimes her hands would rest on the table next to her Macbook Air.  The professors were all fond of Darcy, because she would only answer when she really knew the answer to a question.  Unlike many of the gunners, who longed to hear themselves speak, and who were often wrong, Darcy thought about the question, and often waited for others to speak before she would tell the professor the correct answer. 

The teachers perhaps pitied Darcy in a way, because of her predicament.  You see, when she would put her hands on the table in front of her, with her arms crossed, you could see that she had no hands.  Nobody asked her where they had gone to, or how they were lost.  Instead, she had two big shiny hooks for hands that gleamed under the light of that big classroom. 

I'll remember in property class we were speaking of animals.  We had just finished one of the most crazy cases on property dealing with animals, Pierson v. Post.  I remember that Darcy was called upon during this case.  Mesmerized by her, I sat intently, listening to her words.  I still remember exactly what she said to this day:
In order to obtain title to a ferae naturae (wild animal) a person must take it. The “first to kill and capture” is the superior rule of law. Had Post mortally wounded the animal, it would have been sufficient to show possession since this would have deprived the animal of its natural liberty. However, the plaintiff was only able to show pursuit and therefore acquired no property interest in the animal.
I could not help but notice that her voice was beautiful as she spoke.  She radiated confidence as she stated each word.  She grasped the case almost as well as the professor.  I could tell that he tried to challenge her, but to no avail.  However, what I remember most about that day, October 17th 2010, was when another classmate, let's call him Rod Thompson, raised his gunner hand, and proceeded to ask one of the most idiotic of questions.  "Can a person obtain title to another person if he captures it?"

The professor was obviously not impressed by the fact that this young man did not actually think before he sputtered his ridiculous question.  "What do you think?" the professor asked.

"I... I... Well, no, that would be slavery."

The professor then asked the class what they thought about it.  Most agreed that it would be slavery. 

A few months later I was chosen to explain another case to the class, this one dealing with lost property.  The case was Armory v. Delamirie.  Since the case was so short, I just read the whole thing.  It went like this:
Finder of a jewel may maintain trover.
The plaintiff being a chimney sweeper's boy found a jewel and carried it to the defendant's shop (who was a goldsmith) to know what it was, and delivered it into the hands of the apprentice, who under pretence of weighing it, took out the stones, and calling to the master to let him know it came to three halfpence, the master offered the boy the money, who refused to take it, and insisted to have the thing again; whereupon the apprentice delivered him back the socket without the stones. And now in trover against the master these points were ruled:
1. That the finder of a jewel, though he does not by such finding acquire an absolute property or ownership, yet he has such a property as will enable him to keep it against all but the rightful owner, and consequently may maintain trover.
2. That the action well lay against the master, who gives a credit to his apprentice, and is answerable for his neglect.
3. As to the value of the jewel several of the trade were examined to prove what a jewel of the finest water that would fit the socket would be worth; and the Chief Justice directed the jury, that unless the defendant did produce the jewel, and shew it not to be of the finest water, they should presume the strongest against him, and make the value of the best jewels the measure of their damages: which they accordingly did.
 I remember looking over at Darcy to see if she approved.  By this time I thought she was so smart.  I just knew that she would take the CALI award for property, and perhaps for the rest of the courses.  "Why did she not go to Yale, Stanford, or even Harvard?" I wondered.  Why was she here? 

The professor was not impressed by my reading the case verbatim, but it was correct and he could not scold me for being right.  "Indeed," he said, looking at me.  I could tell he was conjuring quite a challenge for me.  I remember thinking to myself: think logically like a vulcan.  Think logically like a vulcan. 

"Now, tell me, if you were to lay something down and leave the room, and if you were to return the next day, looking for that item, would it be lost, or would it be mislaid?"

I went blank.  What would Spock say?  I was terrified.  I never liked being called on in class.  I never liked being the center of attention.  I was sweating, and I realized that a vulcan would not worry about it, I had been called on, and I could not change that now.  Instead I should focus on the question.  Being right or wrong is irrelevant.  The point is getting through the class.  You are being challenged, and most of the challenge is in your mind. 

"I think it would be lost," I said.  Little Darcy smiled at me, and I knew I was right. 

But I was only half right.  "It could be either," the professor said, "it depends on other factors." 

This was the typical response to the law school game.  Often no matter what you say is right or wrong.  If I was to say "it could be either," I would have heard, "no, it was clearly lost."  I was done.  But Darcy wanted to speak, and up in the air went her shining hook hand.

"Yes," the professor said, smiling. 

"This is kind of a personal question," Darcy said, blushing.
"That is fine," the professor said.  Generally he did not care for personal questions.  The gunners would sometimes ask questions such as "my grandfather bought some property and there's a ton of mice loose in one of the barns.  Are those mice his or does the federal government have constructive possession over the mice?" in which the professor would respond, "well, we went over wild animals, and as the case law states, the animals are owned by nobody until they are captured or deprived of their natural liberty.  However, the government might try to claim ownership of some animals, but probably not mice in a barn."

Darcy continued.  "My hooks, if I was to lay them down and leave, would they be considered a part of me, or just a chattel?"

I wish I would have asked her to the barrister's ball, but I was too shy.  And I figured she had to be taken.  She never spoke of a significant other, but her emerald green eyes and her pouty red lips seemed out of my league.  I was too shy to ever approach her and speak with her.  I knew she could tell I liked her though.  I always watched her speak and always sent smiles her way.

The year eventually came to an end, and as such, so does my tale.  I remember us all sitting there in class while the professor went over last year's exam.  He was telling us what he was looking for and what he did not want to see on the exam.  I was nervous, as this would be the first exam I would be taking in law school.  I was excited as well, as property was my favorite class.  Further, I wanted to prove myself and do great on this test. 

I knew I would not see Darcy on test day.  She had a disability that was obvious.  And I knew that the professors allowed concessions to be made for those with disabilities.  I was told that one of those concessions was six hours to take a three hour exam.  I also heard a couple of the other people in class were taking advantage of that particular concession. 

Darcy is the girl in the blue, on the right side of the picture.

It was a cool day when I arrived at my school to take that exam.  I walked up to the room, with my books and laptop in hand (open book test).  I sat down and got myself ready.  I usually sat in the front of the room, but for test day I would sit in the back.  As I was getting myself ready, I noticed Darcy walk in and sit down.  She tried to open her laptop, but was unable to do it very well.  Usually the girl she sat next to would help her, but she had yet to arrive.  I watched as she tried to open it to no avail.  I decided to make my way down there and open it for her.  I didn't say anything, but she thanked me and smiled, looking up at me with those beautiful eyes of hers.  I smiled back, probably blushing.  I wanted to ask her why she was not taking the test with the added time.  I knew she wanted to be like everyone else though.  She did not want to be seen as disabled, but as a person who had surpassed the challenges of the setback she had been dealt in life.  I was impressed.

The test began.  I typed furiously.  The question was about wild animals.  Perhaps it was for Darcy that the professor wrote it.  I sometimes looked down to see Darcy trying to hit the keys with her hands.  I could hear the noise of her hooks hitting the keyboard, but I did not let it distract me.  I let nothing distract me.  As the hours passed, I looked down towards Darcy and saw that her screen was barely covered with text, and that the words seemed misspelled. 

I must have typed 10,000 words on that exam.  At least it felt like it.  When I was done, I left the room, not speaking to anyone about the exam.  I went home and prepared for my upcoming exams. 

Next spring I found out Darcy was in the bottom of the class and had took a leave of absence.  I never saw her again.

Tuesday, 24 July 2012

Truckin' my way through law school.

To learn some CB lingo, head on over to: http://www.thetruckersreport.com/trucker-slang-and-cb-radio-lingo/
Breaker Breaker, this is Law Rig, anyone else out there?
10-4 Law Rig, this is Mack Daddy.  What's your 20?
Just finishing up this law school run.

Many people wonder why I am still in law school, given that I don't know that I want to practice law.  It is a question I am asked regularly enough that I thought I would let the world know exactly why I am still truckin' my way through law school.

First, I would like to say that when I entered my first year of law school I was a starry eyed 1L who thought law school was the most amazing thing in the world.  I honestly loved briefing cases, learning the 'black letter law' as they called it, and immersing myself in my studies.  I did very well in my first year of law school, as a result.  However, I did not make law review, which was one thing that upset me, and it was part of the reason I grew somewhat complacent during my first semester of being a 2L.  However, even at that time I had no aspirations of quitting law school.  And I knew I was in deep.



I continued to trudge my way through law school, and in the middle of that same semester, I started making this blog.  At first I thought it would be a fun way in which to express my distaste for certain parts of law school.  Some things had begun to annoy me greatly (as is the case with many things in life).  Further, I started to notice other similar blogs about law school.  Some were from kids with rosy glasses and others were from people like Nando, who I stumbled upon.  I read most of his blog entries about different law schools and began thinking about law school a bit differently.  Further, I noticed that my law grades had plummeted.  I began to ask myself some hard questions such as "do I want to do this?"  Further, I did not find my legal internships as enjoyable as I once imagined.  They were nothing like what I saw in the show "Perry Mason" (although I knew they would be different).  I was merely a slave boy working for free.  It was all rather depressing.  However, I figured I would continue through my second year, as I had a lease on an apartment and to quit law school would mean I would be evicted, and that I would not only have dropped out of school, but have an eviction on my record. 


In my second semester of the 2L year I did much better than I did in the first semester.  My grades were somewhat respectable.  That made me feel better, even if it was somewhat meaningless.  It at least showed me that it wasn't me as a person who was a dolt.  And although my grades will not land me a job, I realize that they can at least help my self-esteem, which is worth perhaps more than money.

Now I am about to enter my third year.  A "rising 3L".  I could quit now.  However, I would have to find a job immediately, as I am still paying a small fortune for rent here in New York.  Either that or I can finish the game.  One more year.  I will have the JD, the option to take the bar, the option to do something as far as legal work.  Further, my debt right now is very large.  One more year isn't going to be much of a change as far as it being 'manageable'.  As it stands now, I will have to do IBR (Income Based Repayment) whether or not it's $150k or $200k.  On top of that, I don't mind leaving the US after law school.  I have spent some time in Asia and Europe, as well as Central America, and I know that I could be happy in any of those places.  I have planned on retiring outside of the US for a very long time now.  If I had to leave sooner, I would not bemoan the fact.  Further, I have considered leaving to teach English outside of the US after law school.  Although it's not a glamorous job, it's something I would not mind doing.   In fact, the prospect excites me.

Having weighed all the options for myself, I think the best course of action is to finish.  If I was a 1L still I would have probably dropped out and at least did something else.  However, I am too far in for that now.  So, I shall finish the game, down the boss, and maybe get a little bit of loot, even if it's merely a piece of paper.
Girls Generation - Korean